Aaron Burr, one of the most controversial figures in early American history, is remembered as a daring and enigmatic political leader, a Founding Father who fell from grace. From his role as the third vice president of the United States to his infamous duel with Alexander Hamilton and his mysterious treason trial, Burr’s life was filled with ambition, scandal, and controversy. Here’s a deeper dive into the man who shaped—and shook—the foundations of the young United States.
Early Life: Tragedy and Triumph
Born on February 6, 1756, in Newark, New Jersey, Aaron Burr Jr. was destined for greatness—or so it seemed. His father, Aaron Burr Sr., was the second president of the College of New Jersey (later Princeton University), and his mother, Esther Edwards Burr, was the daughter of the eminent theologian Jonathan Edwards. Tragically, both parents died before Burr turned three, leaving him and his sister Sarah to be raised by relatives. Despite these early hardships, Burr excelled academically, enrolling at Princeton at the age of 13 and graduating at 16.
Initially drawn to theology, Burr shifted gears after two years of study and pursued a career in law. By 1775, he was immersed in legal studies when news of the Battles of Lexington and Concord reached him. The budding lawyer put his studies on hold and enlisted in the Continental Army, setting the stage for his first taste of both glory and contention.
Revolutionary War Heroics
Burr’s military career began with a grueling 300-mile march through Maine’s wilderness as part of Benedict Arnold’s ill-fated expedition to Quebec. His courage shone through during the Battle of Quebec in 1775, where he tried to retrieve the body of General Richard Montgomery under enemy fire. His bravery earned him a promotion to major and later a position on General George Washington’s staff. However, Burr and Washington clashed, reportedly due to Burr’s independent and outspoken nature. He eventually transferred to General Israel Putnam’s command, where he played a critical role in evacuating American troops from New York after the disastrous Battle of Long Island.
Despite his military prowess, Burr’s health began to falter after the harsh winter at Valley Forge and the Battle of Monmouth. In 1779, he resigned from the Continental Army, but his reputation as a war hero preceded him and paved the way for his political ascent.
Legal and Political Ascent
Following the war, Burr quickly established himself as a prominent lawyer in New York, rivaling Alexander Hamilton in skill and reputation. His legal success allowed him to transition into politics, where his charisma and pragmatism helped him secure influential positions. In 1784, he was elected to the New York State Assembly, where he introduced progressive legislation, including a proposal to end slavery. Although the bill failed, it showcased Burr’s willingness to challenge societal norms—even as a slave owner himself.
In 1791, Burr defeated Philip Schuyler, Hamilton’s father-in-law, to win a seat in the U.S. Senate. Aligning himself with the Democratic-Republican Party, Burr became a key player in the growing political rivalry between Thomas Jefferson’s Democratic-Republicans and Hamilton’s Federalists. However, his pragmatic, opportunistic approach—politics as a game of strategy rather than ideology—earned him both admirers and critics.
[title text=”Related stories”]
[blog_posts style=”normal” col_spacing=”small” columns=”3″ columns__md=”1″ slider_nav_style=”circle” slider_bullets=”true” auto_slide=”6000″ cat=”136″ posts=”9″ orderby=”rand” title_size=”small” show_date=”false” excerpt=”false” excerpt_length=”22″ comments=”false” image_height=”66.25%” text_align=”left”]
Vice Presidency and the Duel
The 1800 presidential election was a turning point for Burr. Tied with Thomas Jefferson in the Electoral College, the decision fell to the House of Representatives. Hamilton, despite his disdain for Jefferson, supported him over Burr, calling Burr a man of no principle. Jefferson won, and Burr became vice president, but the political fallout was immediate. Jefferson marginalized Burr throughout his term, and Burr’s subsequent bid for the governorship of New York in 1804 ended in defeat, thanks in part to Hamilton’s efforts to thwart him.
Enraged by Hamilton’s public and private attacks, Burr challenged him to a duel. On July 11, 1804, in Weehawken, New Jersey, Burr fatally shot Hamilton. While dueling was illegal, Burr was never tried. However, the duel obliterated his political career, turning him into a pariah.
The Treason Trial
Burr’s life took an even darker turn after his vice presidency. Moving westward, he became involved in a nebulous scheme involving the newly acquired Louisiana Territory. Allegedly plotting to establish an independent nation or seize Mexican territories, Burr’s actions led to his 1807 arrest for treason. His trial, presided over by Chief Justice John Marshall, captivated the nation. Despite Jefferson’s determination to convict him, Burr was acquitted due to lack of evidence, though his reputation was irreparably damaged.
Later Years and Legacy
Following his trial, Burr spent several years in Europe, lobbying unsuccessfully for support to revive his ambitions. He returned to New York in 1812, living under the shadow of his past scandals. Personal tragedies, including the mysterious disappearance of his beloved daughter Theodosia, further marked his later years. Burr died on September 14, 1836, at the age of 80.
Aaron Burr’s story is one of ambition, brilliance, and controversy. He was a progressive thinker who advocated for women’s education and opposed anti-immigrant sentiment, yet his opportunism and scandals overshadowed his achievements. Remembered as both a hero and a villain, Burr’s life serves as a cautionary tale about the price of unbridled ambition in the tumultuous early days of the American republic.
