Japan History

Japan’s Rival Clans: The Taira and Minamoto

The samurai weren't always Japan's rulers. Their rise to power began under the Minamoto, transforming the nation's leadership.

Japan's Rival Clans: The Taira and Minamoto

In 1180 Japan, a delicate power struggle played out between the Taira and Minamoto clans. Both sought control of the Imperial Court, aiming to dominate the nation. The Taira, having positioned themselves strategically throughout the court and secured vast landholdings, held the upper hand. The Minamoto, tarnished by their support of a losing contender for the throne, had been exiled from the capital and faced a precarious future.

The Taira: Strategic Ascent

Taira No Kiyomori
Taira No Kiyomori

The Taira, descended from former royalty, were strategically relegated to the nobility by Emperor Kanmu (782-805 CE) to ease succession disputes. Yet, ambition persisted – former emperors still wielded tremendous sway, making their support a coveted prize.

Taira Kiyomori, the clan’s leader, emerged as a pivotal figure. He backed former Emperor Go-Shirakawa and, during the 1156 Heiji Incident, rescued him from the Minamoto. Elevated to the highest governmental position below the Emperor, Kiyomori strategically placed Taira loyalists across the provinces. Leveraging their maritime prowess, the Taira (also known as the “Heike”) flourished in trade with Song China.

The Minamoto: Warriors in Decline

Minamoto no Yoshitomo
Minamoto no Yoshitomo

Like the Taira, the Minamoto boasted imperial lineage. However, their reputation lay in military might, not political finesse. Frequent alliances with the waning Fujiwara clan offered the promise of renewed influence, but their tarnished reputation and exile weakened their position. Some Minamoto, undoubtedly skilled warriors, lacked the political acumen needed to truly prevail.

The Heiji Rebellion: Prelude to the Genpei War

The Heiji Rebellion of 1159 served as a watershed moment in Japanese history, marking a temporary setback for the Minamoto clan and ultimately paving the way for the destructive Genpei War.

Night Attack on Sanjo Palace, 13th century, Source: Boston Museum of Fine Arts
Night Attack on Sanjo Palace, 13th century, Source: Boston Museum of Fine Arts

Seeking to exploit the absence of his rival Taira Kiyomori, who was on a pilgrimage, Minamoto Yoshitomo and his ally Fujiwara Nobuyori launched a surprise attack on the imperial palace. While initially successful, Yoshitomo suffered a decisive defeat upon Kiyomori’s return due to a lack of strategic consolidation. Yoshitomo was killed, and while many in his retinue were executed, his young sons Yoritomo, Noriyori, and Yoshitsune were spared and exiled.

The Seeds of the Genpei War

Actor as Emperor Antoku with Tsuki-no-tsubone, by Utagawa Kunisada, 1856, Source: Ukiyo-e.org

In 1180, Taira Kiyomori’s controversial installation of his infant grandson, Antoku, as Emperor sparked the Genpei War (‘Gen’ and ‘Pei’ being alternate readings of the kanji for Minamoto and Taira). Disinherited Prince Mochihito issued a call to arms, seeking to restore what he saw as the rightful imperial lineage. The veteran warrior Minamoto Yorimasa responded but was ultimately defeated. He and his followers retreated across the Uji River, their actions igniting a broader rebellion.

Exiled in the east, Yoritomo Minamoto seized the opportunity. He quickly consolidated his power in the Kanto region, amassing a formidable army fueled by his military skill and widespread resentment towards the Taira. A pivotal moment occurred at the Battle of Fujikawa, where the Taira forces, demoralized and poorly led, were routed by the advancing Minamoto. Taira Kiyomori, weakened by internal conflict and provincial revolts, succumbed to illness in 1181. His surviving sons lacked his strategic acumen, leading to a series of Taira losses that would ultimately determine the war’s outcome.

The Yowa Famine and the Shift of Power in Japan

In agrarian societies, weather patterns hold the power over life and death. The Yowa Famine, beginning in 1180 and lasting two years, devastated western Japan. Harvests failed, food stores were depleted, and armies exacerbated the crisis by requisitioning supplies. Widespread starvation ravaged the western provinces, weakening the Taira clan’s capacity to continue their campaign against the Minamoto.

Pictures of Flowers of Japan, by Ogata Gekko,1898, Source: Japanese Prints
Pictures of Flowers of Japan, by Ogata Gekko,1898, Source: Japanese Prints

Meanwhile, in the capital, the power of the Taira held sway, but the Imperial court was severely weakened by the famine. Like ordinary citizens, they faced scarcity, often resorting to desperate attempts to sell their treasures for food. However, in such dire circumstances, material wealth held little value. Many residents of the capital fled to the mountains, seeking survival in the wilderness.

Sensing the Taira’s vulnerability, Minamoto Yoritomo offered a peace proposal: recognition of Minamoto rule over eastern Japan. The Taira rejected this concession. Unbeknownst to them, Yoritomo had secretly gained favor with the former emperor, Go-Shirakawa. This resulted in the Imperial court legitimizing the Minamoto’s authority and granting their warriors the power to maintain order throughout Japan. This move countered uprisings, safeguarded the nobility, and ultimately paved the way for the establishment of samurai rule.

Kiso Yoshinaka and the Pursuit of Emperor Antoku

Tomoe Gozen, by Kitao Masayoshi, Edo Period, Source: Ukiyo-e.org
Tomoe Gozen, by Kitao Masayoshi, Edo Period, Source: Ukiyo-e.org

During the Genpei War, as Minamoto no Yoritomo solidified his power in the Kanto region, his distant cousin Kiso Yoshinaka emerged as a formidable force in Shinano Province. Driven by a thirst for battle rather than strategic ambition, Yoshinaka, aided by his skilled female warrior Tomoe Gozen, seized Kyoto. The Taira clan retreated westward, taking the young Emperor Antoku and the sacred Imperial Regalia.

Yoshinaka’s arrogance led him to claim leadership of the Minamoto clan based on his conquest. Lacking Yoritomo’s leadership acumen, he was swiftly eliminated by Yoritomo’s brothers, Yoshitsune and Noriyori, at the Battle of Awazu. Yoshinaka and Tomoe’s valiant final stand remains a popular subject in Japanese historical narratives.

Yoshitsune’s Tenacious Campaign

The Battle of Ichi-no-Tani, on folding screen, late 1600s, Source: Wikimedia Commons
The Battle of Ichi-no-Tani, on folding screen, late 1600s, Source: Wikimedia Commons

Following Yoshinaka’s demise, Yoritomo tasked Yoshitsune and Noriyori with relentlessly pursuing the retreating Taira. Their first objective was the heavily fortified Ichi-no-tani. Yoshitsune’s daring charge down a perilous cliffside routed the defenders, denying the Taira a crucial stronghold. The Taira sought refuge at Yashima on Shikoku Island.

Noriyori’s forces, harassed by Taira forces, struggled along the coast before establishing a precarious position in Kyushu. Meanwhile, Yoshitsune amassed a formidable army fueled by defectors eager to escape Taira dominance. His string of victories cemented his reputation as a paragon of samurai virtues: courage, skill, loyalty, and honor – characteristics that would later be enshrined in the bushido code.

The Battle of Dan-no-ura and the Rise of the Kamakura Shogunate

In the culmination of the Genpei War, Minamoto no Yoshitsune strategically navigated the Seto Inland Sea to confront the Taira fleet at Dan-no-ura, a narrow strait near Shimonoseki. The battle commenced on April 25, 1185. Despite being outnumbered, the Minamoto forces capitalized on shifting tides and shrewd tactics.

Initially, the Taira fleet held the advantage, maneuvering skillfully with the prevailing currents. A volley of arrows was exchanged, but as the tide turned, the Minamoto gained ground. Their tight ship formations effectively transformed the naval battle into a land-like conflict, mirroring strategies employed by the Mongols a century later.

A pivotal moment occurred when Taguchi Shigeyoshi, a Taira general, defected to the Minamoto side, exposing the location of Emperor Antoku’s ship. Faced with imminent capture, Antoku’s grandmother, along with the young Emperor and the sacred Imperial Regalia, perished beneath the waves. The Taira suffered a decisive defeat, though the legendary sword Kusanagi-no-Tsurugi remains lost, with only a replica existing today.

Founding of the Kamakura Shogunate

Minamoto no Yoritomo, seeking unchallenged power, systematically eliminated his former allies, including his own brothers Yoshitsune and Noriyori. In 1199, he solidified his rule, receiving the title of sei-i-taishogun (“commander-in-chief of the expeditionary force against the barbarians”). Yoritomo established his capital at Kamakura, ushering in an era of samurai dominance that would endure for centuries. The Kamakura Shogunate, lasting 150 years, set the precedent for subsequent shogunates, shaping Japan until the Meiji Restoration of 1867.

Rate this post

Hiroshi Tanaka

Tip the writer

Is the story useful to you? Consider buy the writer a cup of coffee.

$4.00

TAKE OUR STORIES AWAY