History Affairs

Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz: A Nun, A Poet, and A Feminist

In 17th-century Mexico, Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz defied convention as a nun to become a celebrated intellectual, poet, and feminist voice.

Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz, hailed as Mexico’s Tenth Muse, is among Latin America’s most celebrated nuns and female authors. A self-taught scholar, Sor Juana’s literary contributions are wide-ranging, from eloquent sonnets to popular villancicos, essays, and plays. Her erudition and wit earned her recognition in the elite circles of Mexico’s colonial society but did not ensure a trouble-free life. Sor Juana continuously faced strong opposition from the Catholic Church. Despite this, she left a huge literary legacy and is widely regarded as the first published feminist of the New World.

Childhood & Early Years

The first portrait of Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz by Anonymous, 1673. Source: Jaime Eguiguren Art & Antiques
The first portrait of Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz by Anonymous, 1673. Source: Jaime Eguiguren Art & Antiques

Sor Juana was born in 1948 or 1951 in the viceroyalty of New Spain (present-day Mexico) to Doña Isabel Ramirez de Santillana and Pedro Manuel de Asbaje, a captain from the Basque region of Spain. Sor Juana grew up in a single household, and her father never recognized her as his legitimate daughter, a circumstance that presented a detriment in colonial Mexican society. The nun was acutely aware of this and went on to eloquently address it in one of her poems.

To Sor Juana’s advantage, her mother held a respected position in society as an independent woman of entrepreneurial character, something that was not common in her time. Doña Isabel Ramirez de Santillana operated a small farm and was known for her business acumen, which likely had a positive influence on Sor Juana’s intellectual development and worldview.

Early Displays of Intellectual Prowess

From a very young age, Sor Juana exhibited an extraordinary intellectual capacity and a profound thirst for knowledge. As a child, she taught herself to read and write, and by the age of three, she was already composing poetry. Her precocious abilities and insatiable curiosity drew the attention of the local viceroy, who was reportedly impressed by Sor Juana’s intellectual gifts.

Sor Juana’s parents recognized her exceptional talents and encouraged her educational pursuits, which was quite unusual for a young woman in colonial Mexico. She was permitted to use the family’s library, where she immersed herself in the works of great thinkers and scholars, ranging from ancient philosophers to contemporary theologians.

Portrait of Sister Juana Inés de la Cruz, attributed to Nicolás Enríquez de Vargas, c. 1720-1770. Source: Philadelphia Museum of Art
Portrait of Sister Juana Inés de la Cruz, attributed to Nicolás Enríquez de Vargas, c. 1720-1770. Source: Philadelphia Museum of Art

Education and Early Life Decisions

Despite her parents’ support, Sor Juana faced significant social and cultural barriers in pursuing her intellectual interests. As a woman in a deeply patriarchal society, she was expected to conform to traditional gender roles and duties, such as marriage and domestic responsibilities.

However, Sor Juana made the bold decision to enter the convent at the age of 16, a move that would allow her to devote her life to learning and literary pursuits. This decision was not without its challenges, as the convent was a highly regimented and often restrictive environment. Nevertheless, Sor Juana thrived in this setting, using her time there to continue her self-directed studies and hone her literary skills.

Convent Life & Relationship with the Church

Sor Juana’s decision to enter the convent was a strategic one, as it offered her a unique opportunity to pursue her intellectual passions while navigating the social and cultural constraints of colonial Mexican society. The convent provided her with a relatively autonomous space where she could engage in scholarly activities, read extensively, and develop her literary talents.

Despite the restrictions and discipline of convent life, Sor Juana embraced the opportunity with enthusiasm. She quickly gained a reputation as a gifted scholar and writer, and her works began to circulate among the intellectual elite of Mexico City.

A still from the film I, the Worst of All by Maria Luisa Bemberg, 1990. Source: Museum of Modern Art, New York
A still from the film I, the Worst of All by Maria Luisa Bemberg, 1990. Source: Museum of Modern Art, New York

Navigating the Complexities of the Church

Sor Juana’s relationship with the Catholic Church was a complex and often contentious one. While she was deeply committed to her faith and found fulfillment in the spiritual aspects of convent life, she also had a strong sense of intellectual independence and a willingness to challenge the authority of the Church when she felt it was necessary.

This tension came to a head in the late 1680s, when Sor Juana was forced to publicly recant her scholarly pursuits and pledge to devote herself solely to religious devotion. The catalyst for this was a scathing critique of one of her works by a powerful Mexican bishop, who accused her of heresy and threatened to subject her to the Inquisition.

Sor Juana’s Defiant Response and Subsequent Silencing

Sor Juana’s response to this attack was both defiant and eloquent. In her now-famous “Reply to Sor Filotea,” she fiercely defended her right to engage in intellectual and literary pursuits, arguing that her faith and her scholarship were not mutually exclusive. She also pointed out the hypocrisy of the Church in restricting women’s access to education and intellectual discourse.

Sor Juana Ines de la Cruz by Jennifer Randall. Source: Jennifer Randall Official Site
Sor Juana Ines de la Cruz by Jennifer Randall. Source: Jennifer Randall Official Site

Despite her impassioned defense, Sor Juana was ultimately silenced by the Church’s demands. She was forced to surrender her library and personal papers, and she was prohibited from writing or publishing any further works. This silencing was a devastating blow to Sor Juana, who had dedicated her life to the pursuit of knowledge and the expression of her literary talent.

In the final years of her life, Sor Juana’s health deteriorated, and she was forced to focus her attention on the practical demands of convent life. She continued to write occasional pieces, but her literary output was significantly diminished.

Sor Juana’s death in 1695 was met with an outpouring of grief and recognition from the intellectual and cultural elite of Mexico City. She was hailed as a pioneering feminist, a brilliant scholar, and a literary icon, and her legacy has continued to inspire generations of writers, thinkers, and activists.

Advocacy for Women’s Education

One of the central pillars of Sor Juana’s legacy is her unwavering advocacy for women’s education. She recognized the profound injustice of a society that denied women access to the same educational opportunities afforded to men, and she used her literary and intellectual prowess to challenge this inequality.

Throughout her writings, Sor Juana eloquently argued for the importance of female education, highlighting the ways in which it could empower women to become full and active participants in intellectual and cultural discourse. She believed that education was not only a right but a necessity for the advancement of women and the betterment of society as a whole.

Sor Juana’s Critique of Gender Norms

Sor Juana’s advocacy for women’s education was intimately tied to her broader critique of the rigid gender norms that permeated colonial Mexican society. She recognized that the exclusion of women from educational and intellectual pursuits was rooted in deeply entrenched patriarchal attitudes and beliefs, and she used her writing to challenge these power structures.

In her famous work, “The Answer,” Sor Juana directly confronted the misogynistic attitudes of her male critics, arguing that women were just as intellectually capable as men and deserved equal access to the tools of knowledge and self-expression.

Sor Juana’s Influence on Feminist Thought

Sor Juana’s unwavering commitment to women’s education and her bold critique of gender norms have cemented her place as a pioneering figure in the history of feminist thought. Her writings anticipate many of the core tenets of modern feminism, including the recognition of gender-based discrimination, the importance of equal access to education and intellectual pursuits, and the inherent value of women’s perspectives and contributions.

Sor Juana’s influence can be seen in the work of subsequent generations of female intellectuals and activists, who have built upon her legacy to advance the cause of gender equality and women’s empowerment. Her enduring legacy as a trailblazer and a champion of women’s rights has solidified her place as a towering figure in the annals of Mexican and Latin American history.

Secular Works & Feminist Themes

In addition to her advocacy for women’s education and her defiant stance against the patriarchal norms of her time, Sor Juana’s literary legacy is characterized by the breadth and depth of her creative output. She was a prolific writer who excelled in a wide range of genres, from poetry and drama to essays and theological treatises.

Sor Juana’s secular works, in particular, are notable for their exploration of feminist themes and their challenge to the gender-based restrictions that permeated colonial Mexican society. These works offer a window into the nun’s unyielding commitment to intellectual freedom and her unwavering defense of women’s rights.

Portrait of Sor Juana by Mauricio García Vega
Portrait of Sor Juana by Mauricio García Vega

“Hombres Necios” (Foolish Men): A Scathing Critique of Misogyny

One of Sor Juana’s most famous and influential works is the poem “Hombres Necios” (Foolish Men), which serves as a scathing indictment of the misogynistic attitudes and behaviors that plagued her society. In this piece, Sor Juana skillfully and sarcastically dismantles the hypocrisy of men who simultaneously desire and despise women, holding them to impossible standards of purity and virtue.

The poem’s powerful rhetoric and its uncompromising stance against gender-based double standards have made it a touchstone of feminist literature, both in Latin America and beyond. Sor Juana’s ability to wield language as a tool of social critique and empowerment is on full display in this seminal work.

“Loa to the Divine Narcissus”: A Subversive Exploration of Gender and Power

Another example of Sor Juana’s secular works that engage with feminist themes is her “Loa to the Divine Narcissus,” a dramatic piece that delves into the complex interplay of gender, power, and spirituality. In this work, Sor Juana subverts traditional gender roles and power dynamics, depicting female characters as active agents of their own destiny and challenging the patriarchal structures that seek to confine and control them.

Through the lens of religious allegory, Sor Juana navigates the nuances of gender identity and the ways in which power can be both wielded and subverted. The “Loa to the Divine Narcissus” stands as a testament to Sor Juana’s intellectual depth and her willingness to push the boundaries of conventional thought.

Sor Juana’s Secular Writings and the Legacy of Mexican Feminism

Sor Juana’s secular works, with their unapologetic exploration of feminist themes and their defiant stance against patriarchal oppression, have had a profound and lasting impact on the development of Mexican feminism. Her writings have inspired and empowered countless women to assert their intellectual and creative autonomy, to challenge the gender-based restrictions that have long constrained them, and to demand equal rights and opportunities in all spheres of society.

The legacy of Sor Juana’s secular works, and the way in which they have shaped the trajectory of Mexican feminist thought, is a testament to the enduring power of her words and the enduring relevance of her ideas. As a pioneering voice in the struggle for gender equality, Sor Juana’s influence continues to reverberate through the generations, inspiring new waves of feminist activism and intellectual engagement.

Sor Juana’s remains at the University of the Cloister of Sor Juana in Mexico City. Source: University of the Cloister of Sor Juana
Sor Juana’s remains at the University of the Cloister of Sor Juana in Mexico City. Source: University of the Cloister of Sor Juana

Love Poems & Legacy

In addition to her acclaimed secular works and her advocacy for women’s education, Sor Juana’s literary legacy is also marked by her remarkable collection of love poems. These lyrical compositions, which often explore the complexities of romantic and emotional relationships, stand as a testament to the depth and versatility of Sor Juana’s poetic talents.

Sor Juana’s love poems are notable for their nuanced exploration of gender dynamics and their ability to capture the universal human experiences of love, desire, and heartbreak. Her poetic voice, at once intimate and intellectually-charged, has resonated with readers across generations and has cemented her reputation as one of Mexico’s most celebrated and influential poets.

“Divino Narciso” (The Divine Narcissus): A Poetic Masterpiece

Perhaps Sor Juana’s most renowned love poem is “Divino Narciso” (The Divine Narcissus), a complex and multilayered work that seamlessly blends religious symbolism, mythological references, and deeply personal expression. In this masterpiece, Sor Juana deftly navigates the intersection of spiritual and romantic love, using the metaphor of the divine Narcissus to explore the universal human longing for connection and fulfillment.

The poem’s intricate structure, its rich imagery, and its profound emotional depth have earned it a place among the most celebrated works of Latin American literature. “Divino Narciso” stands as a testament to Sor Juana’s poetic genius and her ability to craft works of enduring beauty and timeless resonance.

Sor Juana’s Legacy and the Continued Relevance of Her Writings

Sor Juana’s literary legacy, encompassing her secular works, her advocacy for women’s education, and her celebrated love poems, has cemented her place as a towering figure in the annals of Mexican and Latin American literature. Her writings have inspired generations of readers, scholars, and activists, who have drawn upon her ideas and her example to advance the cause of gender equality and social justice.

Today, Sor Juana’s legacy continues to resonate with readers and thinkers around the world. Her unwavering commitment to intellectual freedom, her defiant stance against patriarchal oppression, and her poetic mastery have made her a revered and influential figure in the global canon of feminist and literary thought. As the world continues to grapple with the challenges of gender-based discrimination and the ongoing struggle for women’s rights, Sor Juana’s words and ideas remain as relevant and essential as ever.

Conclusion

Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz’s extraordinary life and literary legacy have solidified her place as one of the most important and influential figures in the history of Mexican and Latin American feminism. From her humble beginnings as a precocious child in colonial Mexico, to her celebrated career as a renowned poet, playwright, and essayist, Sor Juana’s journey was marked by both triumph and adversity.

Despite the formidable obstacles she faced, including the relentless opposition of the Catholic Church, Sor Juana remained unwavering in her commitment to intellectual freedom and her advocacy for women’s education and empowerment. Her secular works, infused with feminist themes and a defiant spirit, have inspired generations of thinkers, writers, and activists to challenge the patriarchal structures that have long constrained the aspirations of women.

Sor Juana’s poetic genius, as exemplified in her acclaimed love poems and the masterful “Divino Narciso,” has also cemented her legacy as one of Mexico’s most celebrated literary icons. Her ability to capture the universal human experiences of love, desire, and spirituality, while seamlessly weaving in elements of social critique and feminist thought, has earned her a permanent place in the pantheon of world literature.

Today, as we grapple with the ongoing struggle for gender equality and social justice, Sor Juana’s words and ideas continue to resonate with renewed relevance and urgency. Her unwavering commitment to intellectual freedom, her defiant stance against patriarchal oppression, and her enduring legacy as a pioneering feminist have cemented her status as a towering figure in the history of Mexican and Latin American feminism. Through her life and her writings, Sor Juana Inés de la Cruz has left an indelible mark on the world, inspiring us to continue the fight for a more just and equitable future.

History Affairs
Kim Luu is a writer specializing in Chinese history and civilization. Born and raised in Vietnam, a country with a shared cultural heritage with China, he developed an early fascination and conducted in-depth studies on the greatest civilization in East Asia.

Support us!

The History Affairs project aims to be a free gateway to historical knowledge for everyone, driven by our passion and commitment. Your financial support makes this work living on. Every dollar will be transformed into enriching content by our writers.

$5.00

EXPLORE OUR STORIES