The Colosseum, the heart of Roman entertainment, witnessed countless spectacles, from gladiatorial combat to exotic animal displays. Ridley Scott’s Gladiator II revisits this iconic arena, showcasing a new champion facing challenges both human and animal.
While the film promises thrilling action, it also raises questions about the historical accuracy of its depictions. Let’s delve into the historical record to separate fact from cinematic license, exploring the intriguing aspects of Roman entertainment brought to life on the big screen.
Did Gladiators Really Face Rhinos in the Arena?
One of the most captivating scenes in the Gladiator II trailer involves a gladiator facing the charge of a rhinoceros. While the visual is undoubtedly striking, it’s important to note that there’s no historical evidence to suggest gladiators ever fought rhinos in the arena. Rhinos were indeed present in ancient Rome, but their appearances were more likely reserved for exotic animal displays rather than direct combat with humans.
Historical records indicate that a rhinoceros was part of the inaugural games of the Colosseum in 80 AD. However, it wasn’t pitted against gladiators. Instead, it faced other animals in a display of power and exoticism. Other mentions of rhinos in Rome typically involve their presence in menageries, where they were admired as rare and fascinating creatures.
The Roman fascination with foreign and wild animals fueled the development of beast spectacles, or venationes. These events initially began as non-violent displays of captured animals, such as war elephants. However, over time, they evolved into staged hunts and fights, becoming a staple of Roman entertainment.
The emperors used these spectacles to showcase their power and the vastness of the Roman Empire. Thousands of animals, including lions, tigers, elephants, and bears, were brought from across the empire to be displayed and often killed in the arena. These hunts were not the domain of gladiators; instead, specially trained hunters known as venatores were tasked with facing the beasts, armed with spears and other weapons.
The venationes could also involve fights between animals, such as bulls against elephants or bears. Interestingly, these animal hunts outlasted gladiatorial combat as a form of popular entertainment. As the Roman Empire declined, and resources became scarcer, domestically reared “wild” animals were increasingly used in these spectacles.
Sea Battles in the Colosseum
Gladiator II features a dramatic sea battle staged within the Colosseum. While this might seem like an incredible feat of engineering and imagination, historical records suggest that such spectacles, known as naumachiae, did indeed take place.
Naumachiae were extravagant and expensive events, reserved for special occasions and often used to celebrate military victories or imperial power. The first recorded naumachia was held by Emperor Augustus in 2 BC on an artificial lake. It involved 30 large ships and thousands of participants, including marines and rowers.
The participants in naumachiae were typically convicted criminals or prisoners of war. They were expected to fight to the death or drown, although demonstrating exceptional fighting skills or courage could earn them a pardon.
Perhaps the grandest naumachia was staged by Emperor Claudius on Lake Fucinus. This massive spectacle involved 100 ships and an estimated 19,000 participants. It’s at this event that the famous phrase “Ave Imperator, morituri te salutant” (“Hail, Emperor, those who are about to die salute you”) is believed to have been uttered, a phrase often mistakenly attributed to gladiators in popular culture.
While some historical accounts, often written long after the alleged events, claim that the Colosseum itself was flooded for a naumachia at its inauguration, this remains a subject of debate among historians. However, evidence suggests that the Colosseum’s engineering did allow for the possibility of flooding the arena, at least in its early years, to accommodate such spectacular naval battles.
More Affairs
Thumbs Up or Thumbs Down
Gladiator II also depicts the iconic “thumbs up” and “thumbs down” gestures as signals of life or death for a defeated gladiator. However, the historical reality of these gestures is more nuanced and less straightforward than often portrayed in popular culture.
The arena was a vast and noisy environment, and hand signals were commonly used for communication. When a gladiator was defeated, he could appeal for mercy by raising the index finger of his right hand or even his entire hand. These gestures were recognized pleas for clemency.
When the crowd desired the death of a fighter, they used the gesture known as pollice verso, which literally translates to “turned thumb.” Interestingly, historical sources don’t specify the direction of the thumb in this gesture. When the hand was waved, it signaled that the victorious gladiator should deliver the killing blow.
Those who wished to spare the defeated but valiant gladiator used the gesture pollice compresso, which meant “compressed thumb.” This gesture was often concealed from view to avoid confusion with the pollice verso.
Gladiators were valuable assets, and their promoters, who paid substantial fees to hire them, were hesitant to lose their investment if a gladiator died. The crowd’s opinion often influenced the final decision, as promoters wanted to maintain their favor. However, the exact role of the “thumbs up” or “thumbs down” gestures in the final decision remains a matter of historical debate.
The popular association of these gestures with life or death likely stems from the 1872 painting “Pollice Verso” by French artist Jean-Léon Gérôme. The painting depicts vestal virgins giving the “thumbs down” signal, further solidifying this image in popular culture.
The Enduring Allure of Roman Spectacle
Gladiator II promises to transport audiences back to the thrilling and brutal world of Roman entertainment. While the film takes certain creative liberties, it’s grounded in the historical reality of gladiatorial combat, exotic animal displays, and the grandeur of the Colosseum.
By exploring the historical context behind these spectacles, we gain a deeper appreciation for the complexities of Roman society and the enduring fascination with this era. The film’s blend of action, drama, and historical inspiration ensures that the legacy of the Colosseum and its gladiators will continue to captivate audiences for generations to come.
