The early decades of Christianity, following the death of the “big three” apostles—Paul, Peter, and James—ushered in a period of transformation and adaptation for the nascent faith. Often referred to as the Subapostolic Age, this era witnessed the evolution of church practices, the emergence of various Jewish and Gentile Christian groups, and the production of a wide range of literature that would shape the future of Christian thought and organization.
The Transitional Period of the Subapostolic Age
The first century of Christianity was dominated by the missionary work and teaching of the apostles. However, the mid-first century brought seismic changes. With the martyrdom of key leaders like Paul, Peter, and James by the mid-sixties—and the catastrophic events of the Jewish revolt culminating in the destruction of Jerusalem—the Christian movement found itself at a crossroads. Without a comprehensive narrative like that found in the Book of Acts, scholars have had to piece together the church’s development through fragmentary historical records, sociological theories, and surviving texts.
The removal of Jerusalem as the central hub of the early church had profound effects. Not only did this shift diminish the influence of Jewish traditions in the larger Christian narrative, but it also paved the way for the emergence of Gentile believers as a dominant force within Christianity. In this shifting landscape, early Christians faced the challenge of maintaining continuity with their Jewish heritage while adapting to new cultural and theological environments.
Strands of Jewish Christianity
In the late first and early second centuries, as Gentile communities grew and the Christian identity began to diverge from its Jewish roots, various forms of Jewish Christianity emerged. These groups struggled to navigate their dual identity as both adherents to Jewish religious practices and followers of Jesus. The term “Jewish Christianity” itself has been used in different ways—sometimes broadly to describe any Jewish influence on Christianity, and at other times specifically to denote those ethnic Jews whose practices were seen as heretical by the rising Gentile church.
The alienation between Jewish and Gentile Christians became increasingly pronounced. The destruction of the Temple in 70 AD and subsequent events, such as the banishment of Jews from Jerusalem after the Bar Kokhba revolt in 135 AD, effectively removed Jerusalem as the spiritual and geographical center of early Christianity. As a result, many synagogues expelled any remaining Christian elements, leaving Jewish Christians isolated from both their Jewish and Gentile counterparts.
Despite this separation, several distinct groups within Jewish Christianity left their mark on early Christian literature and theology. Three major strands are particularly noteworthy:
The Ebionites
The Ebionites became the most frequently discussed group among early Gentile Christian writers, who labeled them as heretical. Centered around the veneration of James the Just, these Jewish Christians held a strict view of monotheism. They rejected key doctrines such as the virgin birth, viewing Jesus as a true prophet and the new Moses rather than a divine figure. The Ebionites emphasized that Gentile converts needed to observe the Mosaic Law, including practices like circumcision, Sabbath observance, and dietary restrictions. Their teachings underscored a theology rooted in humility and poverty, reflecting the values associated with “the poor” as described in Hebrew scripture. Their gospel of choice was Matthew, supplemented by other texts that provided further insight into their beliefs and practices.
The Nazoraeans
Another group, often called the Nazoraeans (or Nazaraeans), occupied a more moderate position. They maintained a commitment to Jewish law while also welcoming Gentile converts without imposing these strict observances on them. This attempt at bridging the divide between Jewish and Gentile practices, however, proved to be a tenuous balance. The Nazoraeans eventually faded from prominence, unable to sustain a coherent identity in a rapidly changing religious landscape.
The Elkesaites
A third strand came in the form of the Elkesaites, a group that absorbed elements of Gnostic thought. Their association with a prophet named Elkesai and a corresponding book of revelations from the early second century hints at the eclectic nature of early Christian spirituality. Some historical accounts even link the Elkesaites with the later developments in Gnosticism, particularly through the influence of Mani, the founder of Manichaeism. Though fragmentary, the surviving accounts of the Elkesaites provide a fascinating glimpse into the diversity of early Jewish Christian thought.
Beyond these distinct groups, broader Jewish influences continued to be present within mainstream Christianity. Texts like the Didache and other writings that would later form part of the New Testament Apocrypha reveal deep roots in Jewish ethical and liturgical traditions. Even as the Christian church distanced itself from overtly Jewish practices, its underlying theological framework retained many of the language, symbols, and narratives of its Jewish heritage.
Literature and Developments in Gentile Christianity
In contrast to the sparse records left by Jewish Christian groups, the writings produced by Gentile Christians during the late first to mid-second century provide a wealth of insight into the evolving structure and theology of the early church. These texts, often categorized under the umbrella term “Apostolic Fathers,” include letters, treatises, and manuals that addressed both doctrinal and practical matters. Although these writings sometimes lack the inspirational depth of the apostolic era, they were crucial in preserving the core message of Christianity and in establishing the institutional framework for the church.
The Apostolic Fathers: Preserving and Adapting the Faith
The Apostolic Fathers were early Christian writers who, though not direct disciples of the apostles, were seen as the immediate successors in maintaining the apostolic tradition. Their works were instrumental in guiding the church through internal disputes, external persecutions, and the challenge of adapting to a rapidly changing world. Some of the key writings in this category include:
- The Didache: Often titled “The Teaching of the Lord through the Twelve Apostles to the Nations,” the Didache is a comprehensive manual for church life. Divided into sections that discuss moral instruction (the “Two Ways” of life and death), liturgical practices, and eschatological expectations, the Didache reflects the enduring influence of Jewish ethical teachings and the emerging Christian identity. Its instructions on baptism, fasting, prayer, and communal worship underscore the practical concerns of a community striving to remain faithful in an increasingly secular world.
- The Epistle of Barnabas: This treatise, which circulates with the name Barnabas attached to it, addresses the contentious debate over the relevance of Jewish law for Christians. Arguing that the covenant with God had shifted from the Jews to the followers of Jesus, the Epistle of Barnabas interprets Old Testament practices in a symbolic or spiritual light. It reinterprets circumcision, sacrifice, and temple worship as allegories for spiritual truths, aiming to reconcile the Jewish heritage with the new Christian dispensation.
- 1 Clement and 2 Clement: The letters attributed to Clement of Rome are among the earliest attempts to promote church unity in the face of internal strife. Written as addresses to communities in Corinth and elsewhere, these letters emphasize themes such as humility, obedience, and mutual love among believers. They also provide early evidence for the development of a structured church hierarchy, with clear roles for bishops, presbyters, and deacons. By drawing on both Jewish scripture and contemporary Greco-Roman thought, Clement’s letters articulate a vision of the church as a divinely ordained institution.
- The Shepherd (Pastor) by Hermas: Hermas’ work, a blend of visions, parables, and commandments, offers insight into the moral and spiritual challenges facing early Christians. While the text’s structure and style have led some scholars to question its unity, its overall message is one of repentance, renewal, and the constant need to preserve the grace received at baptism. Hermas provides practical guidance on dealing with sin in the believer’s life, reflecting the concerns of a community living in a hostile and rapidly changing world.
- Ignatius of Antioch: Perhaps one of the most impassioned voices from this period, Ignatius wrote a series of letters while on his journey to martyrdom. His letters, addressed to various churches and leaders, underscore the importance of unity and the central role of church hierarchy in maintaining doctrinal purity. Ignatius vehemently opposed both the Docetic views—which suggested that Jesus only appeared to be human—and the Judaizing tendencies that threatened to dilute the distinctiveness of Christian belief. By insisting on the authority of the bishop as a unifying figure, Ignatius laid the groundwork for the future organizational structure of the church.
- Polycarp of Smyrna and Papias of Hierapolis: Other notable figures, such as Polycarp and Papias, contributed to the theological and pastoral discussions of the time. Polycarp’s letter to the Philippians reflects his deep commitment to righteous living and adherence to apostolic teachings, while Papias is remembered for his early testimonies regarding the origins of the Gospels—particularly his assertion that Matthew originally composed his Gospel in Hebrew.
Each of these writings not only addressed immediate concerns but also helped to shape a theological tradition that would endure for centuries. They provide us with valuable historical insights into how early Gentile Christians reconciled their Jewish heritage with their newfound identity in a predominantly Greco-Roman world.
The Emergence of Apocryphal Literature
Alongside the more canonical writings of the Apostolic Fathers, a rich body of apocryphal literature also emerged during the Subapostolic Age. These works, though later regarded by some as heretical or of lesser spiritual authority, offer a window into the diverse and sometimes experimental nature of early Christian thought.
The New Testament Apocrypha can be grouped into several categories:
- Gospels: Works such as the Gospel of Thomas, Gospel of Peter, and the Protevangelium of James represent alternative accounts of the life, teachings, and passion of Jesus. The Gospel of Thomas, in particular, is notable for its collection of sayings attributed to Jesus, some of which resemble those found in the canonical Gospels. Although its association with Gnostic thought has led to debates over its classification, many scholars argue that it reflects an early and ascetic strand of Christian spirituality.
- Acts: The apocryphal acts—such as the Acts of Peter, Acts of Paul, and Acts of John—offer imaginative and sometimes extravagant narratives of the apostles’ missionary journeys. These texts, rich in miracle stories and ascetic themes, mirror the Hellenistic novel tradition and serve to reinforce the heroic status of the apostles, even as they deviate from the historical record.
- Epistles and Apocalypses: In addition to gospels and acts, there are epistolary and apocalyptic writings, such as the Epistle of the Apostles and the Apocalypse of Peter. These works often employ visionary language and symbolic imagery to explore themes of divine judgment, salvation, and the end of the world. While their theological content might not always align perfectly with what later became orthodox doctrine, they nonetheless capture the fervent hopes and spiritual anxieties of early Christian communities.
- Other Writings: Beyond these categories, other texts such as the Ascension of Isaiah, the Testaments of the Twelve Patriarchs, and the Odes of Solomon illustrate the wide-ranging efforts of early Christians to articulate their beliefs. Some of these works blend Jewish traditions with emerging Christian ideas, while others reveal the influence of pagan literature and myth.
Though the apocryphal texts often present theological and literary challenges for modern readers, they are invaluable in understanding the diversity of early Christian expression. They reflect a time when boundaries between orthodoxy and heterodoxy were fluid and when the search for spiritual meaning could take many forms.
More Affairs
The Enduring Legacy of the Subapostolic Age
The Subapostolic Age was, in many ways, a period of settling and transition. As the early church moved away from its immediate apostolic origins, it was forced to confront new internal challenges—such as maintaining unity in the face of divergent theological views and establishing a reliable organizational structure. The writings produced during this time, whether by Jewish Christians or Gentile leaders, attest to the dynamic and often contentious process of defining what it meant to be a follower of Jesus in an ever-changing world.
Several enduring themes emerge from the literature of this period:
- The Tension Between Jewish Heritage and Gentile Adaptation: As the early church expanded beyond its Jewish roots, it had to reconcile the continuity of its scriptural traditions with the practical realities of a predominantly Gentile membership. This tension is evident in the debates over the observance of the Mosaic Law, the interpretation of Old Testament rituals, and the very identity of what it meant to be “Christian.”
- The Importance of Church Unity and Order: Many of the Apostolic Fathers and early Christian apologists were preoccupied with the threat of division within the church. Whether through the intervention of figures like Clement and Ignatius or through the allegorical reinterpretations offered in texts like the Epistle of Barnabas, a strong emphasis was placed on maintaining a unified and orderly community. The development of a structured hierarchy, with clearly defined roles for bishops, presbyters, and deacons, was a direct response to these challenges.
- Ethical Living in a Complex World: As the initial fervor of the apostolic age gave way to the everyday realities of life under Roman rule, there was a renewed focus on practical ethics and moral discipline. Works like the Didache and Hermas’ Shepherd underscore the enduring need for guidance on issues such as repentance, righteousness, and community support. This focus on ethical living would continue to influence Christian thought and practice for centuries.
- The Dynamic Nature of Early Christian Thought: The sheer variety of texts—from the authoritative letters of Clement and Ignatius to the more experimental apocryphal gospels and acts—reveals that early Christian thought was far from monolithic. Instead, it was a dynamic and evolving conversation that sought to articulate a response to new challenges while remaining rooted in the teachings of Jesus and the apostles.
Conclusion
The Subapostolic Age was a formative period in the history of Christianity—a time marked by transition, conflict, and creative theological exploration. With the loss of its foremost leaders and the upheavals in its Jewish homeland, the early church was compelled to redefine its identity and to establish a structure that could sustain its growing and diverse membership. The various strands of Jewish Christianity, alongside the writings of the Apostolic Fathers and the rich body of apocryphal literature, collectively paint a picture of a community in flux, struggling to maintain fidelity to its origins while adapting to new realities.
Today, these early texts offer modern readers a glimpse into the challenges and triumphs of a community striving to preserve its sacred traditions in the face of adversity. They remind us that the pursuit of spiritual truth is an ongoing journey—one that often involves navigating tensions between heritage and innovation, unity and diversity, tradition and change. In exploring the Subapostolic Age, we gain not only historical insight but also a deeper appreciation for the enduring quest for meaning that continues to shape the Christian faith.
